How to Choose the Right Person as Your Power of Attorney

Table of Contents

Estate planning is never easy — emotionally or logistically. One of the most critical decisions you’ll make is choosing the right person as your Power of Attorney (POA).

A few years ago, I helped my aunt through this process. She wanted someone she could trust to handle her finances if she ever couldn’t, but she wasn’t sure who would be the best fit. Watching her weigh loyalty, financial know-how, and availability taught me a valuable lesson: this is not a decision to make lightly.

This guide walks you through how to make this important choice with confidence, clarity, and peace of mind.

Understanding What a Power of Attorney Does

A Power of Attorney (POA) is a legal document that allows someone (called the agent or attorney-in-fact) to make decisions on your behalf.

There are different types:

• Financial POA – Handles bank accounts, investments, real estate, and bills.

• Medical POA (Health Care Proxy) – Makes health care decisions if you’re incapacitated.

• Durable POA – Remains valid even if you become mentally or physically unable to make decisions.

• Limited or Special POA – Grants authority for a specific purpose or time period.

📖 Reference: American Bar Association – Power of Attorney Overview

Key Qualities to Look for in a POA Agent

Choosing someone simply because they’re family or close isn’t enough. Your agent should have:

• Trustworthiness – You’re granting access to your finances and personal decisions.

• Financial competence – Understanding of bills, taxes, or investments is a plus.

• Communication skills – Must talk clearly with banks, doctors, lawyers, and family.

• Geographic proximity – Someone nearby can act more quickly in emergencies.

• Willingness – Not everyone wants or feels comfortable taking on this role.

Step-by-Step Guide to Choosing the Right Person

Step 1: List Potential Candidates

Write down a few people you trust implicitly. These could include:

• A spouse or partner

• Adult children

• Siblings or close relatives

• A trusted friend

• A professional fiduciary or attorney

Step 2: Assess Their Strengths and Weaknesses

Ask yourself:

• Are they good under pressure?

• Do they understand financial basics?

• Are they emotionally stable?

• Do they respect my wishes, even if they disagree?

Step 3: Talk to Them Honestly

Transparency is critical. Explain:

• The responsibilities involved

• Your expectations

• Your values regarding finances and medical care

• How they can decline if they feel unprepared

Step 4: Formalize with Legal Counsel

Once you’ve chosen, meet with an estate planning attorney to draft or update your POA documents. Laws differ by state or country, so professional guidance ensures validity.

Real-World Examples

1. Case Study: Financial Clarity Pays Off
   Maria, a small business owner, appointed her accountant brother as her POA. When she faced a sudden surgery, he seamlessly managed payroll and kept the business afloat.

2. Case Study: Emotional Loyalty Without Experience
   John named his eldest daughter out of love, but she struggled with medical jargon and banking procedures, causing delays. They later revised the POA to include a financially savvy cousin as co-agent.

3. Case Study: Professional Fiduciary for Neutrality
   When siblings disagreed, one family hired a licensed fiduciary. This neutral party managed estate matters fairly, avoiding family conflict during a stressful time.

Comparison Table: Family vs. Professional POA Agents

Criteria	Family/Friend Agent	Professional Fiduciary/Attorney
Emotional Connection	High	Low (neutral)
Availability	Varies	Typically available
Cost	Usually no fee	Hourly or flat fee applies
Expertise	Depends on individual	Legally trained or certified
Family Conflict Risk	Sometimes higher	Usually lower

Common Mistakes to Avoid

• Choosing by guilt or obligation rather than capability

• Not updating your POA when life changes (marriage, divorce, death)

• Failing to name an alternate in case your first choice can’t serve

• Not informing your family about who you’ve chosen and why

Conclusion: Take the Time, Do It Right

Your Power of Attorney is your voice when you can’t speak for yourself. By carefully choosing someone capable, trustworthy, and willing, you protect not only your finances and health care decisions — but also give peace of mind to those who care about you.

💬 Your Turn:
Have you already chosen your Power of Attorney? What qualities mattered most to you? Share your thoughts in the comments below or sign up for our free estate planning checklist.